TL;DR
- Lesbian couple sues Key West over fines.
- City threatened daily fines for rainbow fence.
- ACLU supports the couple’s lawsuit.
- Claims of selective enforcement and censorship.
- Case highlights First Amendment rights.
In a colorful showdown that’s making waves in the Sunshine State, a lesbian couple in Key West is taking a stand against the city after being hit with daily fines for their fabulous rainbow-painted fence. That’s right, folks! Coley Sohn and Linda Bagley-Sohn decided to show their pride by painting their fence in vibrant rainbow hues, a bold protest against Florida’s recent decision to strip away Pride crosswalks. But instead of applause, they got a hefty dose of city fines!
After Governor Ron DeSantis issued demands on June 30, 2025, to remove decorated crosswalks, the couple’s colorful display became a target. According to their lawsuit, they weren’t alone in their rainbow revolution—over 50 neighbors joined in solidarity, painting their own fences in support. But guess who got singled out? You guessed it—the Bagley-Sohns, thanks to a complaint from a less-than-supportive neighbor.
The city slapped them with a jaw-dropping fine of up to $250 per day unless they painted their fence back to boring white. Talk about a buzzkill! In December 2025, they applied for a permit to keep their rainbow flair, but the city denied it in February, claiming their display violated some obscure code about unapproved colors. So, on March 26, they reluctantly repainted their fence white to avoid further penalties. But they weren’t going down without a fight!
With the backing of the ACLU of Florida, the couple is arguing that the city’s actions amount to unconstitutional viewpoint discrimination and political censorship. “No one should lose their right to speak out simply because those in power disagree with the message,” Sohn declared. And she’s got a point! The lawsuit highlights how other colorful homes in Key West were never cited, suggesting that the rainbow pattern associated with LGBTQ+ Pride is what really triggered the city’s crackdown.
ACLU attorney Nicholas Warren chimed in, stating, “The government cannot enforce a law against people who express particular messages or views, while ignoring violations with different content or messages.” Preach! This case is set to raise important questions about First Amendment rights and whether local governments can play favorites when it comes to the messages people express through their homes.
The Bagley-Sohns are not just fighting for their fence; they’re standing up for every LGBTQ+ person who has ever faced discrimination for simply being themselves. So, what’s next for this rainbow revolution? Stay tuned as we keep an eye on this vibrant legal battle that’s sure to inspire others to paint their truths, loud and proud!