Irish pop star Róisín Murphy has found herself in the midst of a public discourse after comments attributed to her raised concerns over the use of puberty blockers by transgender kids. A screenshot of a comment from her personal Facebook account went viral, sparking intense reactions. In the comment, she expressed reservations about the use of puberty blockers, stating, “But puberty blockers ARE F**KED, absolutely desolate, big Pharma laughing all the way to the bank.”
While the catalyst for Murphy’s comment remains unclear, her remarks swiftly triggered criticism. Notably, Murphy’s fanbase includes a significant LGBTQ+ following. Critics accused her of perpetuating anti-trans misinformation that has contributed to moral panic surrounding gender-affirming care for trans kids in the U.S. and U.K.
Puberty blockers are prescribed to both cisgender and transgender youth to alleviate distress linked to early onset puberty and gender dysphoria. However, many laws only prohibit the use of puberty blockers for trans kids, despite major medical organizations supporting gender-affirming healthcare, including puberty blockers, as safe and effective.
In response to the backlash, Murphy posted a lengthy statement on Twitter. Expressing regret, she acknowledged her lack of expertise on the subject and the division her comments caused. She emphasized that her concern stemmed from a place of care, even as she recognized that fixed views aren’t helpful. Murphy expressed her intention to step back from the public conversation and clarified that her goal isn’t to turn it into a campaign.
However, Murphy’s statement did not disavow her initial comments or provide a comprehensive explanation of her views. Notably, she did not address her stance on transgender people’s rights to necessary healthcare. As the backlash continues, it remains uncertain whether Murphy’s comments will be fully clarified or retracted.
Murphy joins a growing list of musicians who have faced criticism for their anti-trans remarks, highlighting the ongoing need for informed and respectful dialogue surrounding transgender issues in the entertainment industry and beyond.
