Season 3 of The Traitors has brought a new level of visibility to the show, but with that popularity comes a recurring issue: the resurgence of dominant alliances led by straight men. Despite the show’s inclusive and queer-friendly reputation, these alliances reflect a troubling trend in reality TV history, where loyalty among straight men often sidelines more diverse contestants.
The so-called “Straightors” alliance—led by reality veterans like Boston Rob Mariano, Derrick Levasseur, and Wes Bergmann—has begun to reshape the dynamics of the competition. These alliances often exploit players from marginalized groups, using them for numbers while keeping the ultimate power within their inner circle. For LGBTQ contestants, this creates a precarious position, where their contributions are recognized only as long as they serve the alliance’s goals.
A Familiar Power Dynamic
Such strategies have been a staple in shows like Big Brother and Survivor, where alliances of straight men often dominate. However, the inclusion of LGBTQ contestants and women has introduced new challenges to these power structures. Players like Bob the Drag Queen and Britney Haynes exemplify the strategic resistance to these alliances, demonstrating how representation can shift the narrative.
Yet, as Boston Rob and Derrick rely on outdated tactics, many viewers and contestants alike are pushing back. “The reign of the bro is changing,” noted Big Brother winner Andy Herren, emphasizing how diverse casts are dismantling these traditional alliances. Still, the challenge remains for shows like The Traitors to balance entertainment with a commitment to equity.
Bro Alliances in a Changing Era
While players like Dylan Efron and Wes Bergmann may contribute unique personalities to the alliance, their alignment with the “Straightors” underscores a broader issue in reality television: the exclusion of genuine inclusivity in favor of predictable power dynamics. For LGBTQ players, the stakes go beyond the game, reflecting societal struggles against systemic marginalization.
The trajectory of The Traitors Season 3 will reveal whether these alliances can sustain their dominance or if diverse players will finally disrupt their control. The challenge for the series lies in ensuring that its narrative evolves with its cast, offering an equitable platform where every contestant has a chance to shine.