The Vatican commemorated the first anniversary of Pope Benedict XVI’s death, an event that reignited the debate over the Church’s approach to same-sex couples. Cardinal Gerhard Mueller, the Church’s former doctrinal head, and Archbishop Georg Gaenswein, Benedict’s private secretary, highlighted the occasion. Both, echoing the conservative stance, played pivotal roles in an event organized by the U.S.-based EWTN network.
Mueller, in a statement, asserted that the declaration permitting blessings for same-sex couples—a development post-Benedict—would have been unlikely during Benedict’s tenure. He criticized the declaration, made on December 18, for its ambiguity and potential implications. While the declaration specifies that such blessings should not mimic matrimonial sacraments, it has been perceived by some LGBT advocates as a step towards same-sex marriage acceptance in the Church.
A Reflection on Church Doctrine and Inclusivity
Mueller, removed from his Vatican position after Benedict’s resignation, emphasized the non-existence of “homosexual matrimony” in the Church’s doctrine, referencing prevailing ideological shifts. His comments highlight the ongoing tension within the Church regarding its stance on LGBT issues.
Pope Francis, while marking the anniversary, commended Benedict for his service. Francis’ brief acknowledgment underlined Benedict’s enduring influence within the Vatican. However, Mueller’s remarks illustrate the doctrinal divergences between him and Francis, despite a personally amicable relationship.
Benedict’s Resignation: A Continuing Divide
The Mass at St. Peter’s Basilica, led by Gaenswein, further underscored the emotional and divisive aftermath of Benedict’s resignation. The event revealed the schism within the Church, exacerbated by Benedict’s unique position as ‘pope emeritus’. Gaenswein, reflecting on Benedict’s decision to resign—anticipating a short remaining lifespan—expressed hope for Benedict’s eventual sainthood.
As the Church navigates these doctrinal and ideological divides, the legacy of Benedict XVI continues to be a focal point of discussion and reflection, particularly in relation to the Church’s position on LGBT matters.