In a recent broadcast that sparked widespread discussion, Shivani Dave, a non-binary journalist, faced misgendering by TalkTV host Julia Hartley-Brewer. During the segment, Hartley-Brewer introduced Dave with incorrect pronouns, prompting Dave to correct her politely, emphasizing their use of “they/them” pronouns. However, the host responded by stating her preference for what she called “correct grammar,” insisting on using “she” and “her” based on her perception of grammatical correctness and identity.
The Pronoun Controversy
This incident on TalkTV not only highlighted the personal implications for Dave but also ignited a broader conversation about linguistic respect and the recognition of non-binary identities in media. Hartley-Brewer defended her stance by arguing against the grammar of using ‘they’ as a singular pronoun, a point contested by linguistic experts and advocates for inclusivity who affirm that ‘they’ has been used as a singular pronoun for centuries. Despite the tension, Dave maintained composure, stressing the importance of respectful language to foster a more inclusive society. They pointed out that respectful language usage can significantly reduce negative mental health outcomes for LGBTQ+ individuals, as supported by major psychological associations.
A Reflection on Media and Society
This episode serves as a critical reflection on the media’s role in shaping societal attitudes towards gender and identity. As debates about language and personal identity continue to evolve, the insistence on traditional language norms by some media figures contrasts sharply with a growing recognition of diverse identities. This discourse not only affects individuals like Dave but also influences the broader cultural understanding of gender fluidity and respect in public discourse.