The Pink Times
Aa
  • Home
  • World News
    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • China
    • Europe
    • India
    • Middle East
    • United Kingdom
    • United States
  • Culture
    • Art
    • Drag
    • Books
    • Entertainment
    • Drag
    • Fashion
    • History
    • Love
    • People
    • PhotographyTrending
    • Religion
  • Politics
    Politics
    Show More
    Top News
    Ron DeSantis: Unyielding Attacks on LGBTQ Rights in Florida
    May 14, 2023
    Uganda Enacts Harsh Anti-LGBTQ Law, Drawing Global Outrage and Potential Sanctions
    May 29, 2023
    Disney Sues Florida Governor Over “Don’t Say Gay” Bill: Will This Hurt DeSantis’ 2024 Presidential Bid?
    April 27, 2023
    Latest News
    Colorado County Commissioner Faces Backlash for Alleged Anti-LGBTQ Slur
    October 2, 2023
    California Governor Appoints Laphonza Butler, First Openly LGBTQ+ Senator to Represent the State
    October 2, 2023
    Greek Entrepreneur Stefanos Kasselakis Assumes Leadership in Politics
    October 2, 2023
    Rep. Lauren Boebert’s Amendment to USDA Bill Targets LGBTQ+ Workplace Education
    October 2, 2023
  • Law
    Law
    Show More
    Top News
    Disney Sues Florida Governor Over “Don’t Say Gay” Bill: Will This Hurt DeSantis’ 2024 Presidential Bid?
    April 27, 2023
    Brooklyn Dancer O’Shea Sibley Fatally Stabbed After Voguing, NYPD’s Hate Crimes Task Force Investigates
    August 2, 2023
    Five dead, 18 injured in shooting at gay nightclub in Colorado, police say
    November 20, 2022
    Latest News
    India: Telangana High Court Strikes Down 1919 Act, Ensuring Rights for Transgender Community
    October 2, 2023
    Two Men Plead Guilty in Hate Crime Assault Against Transgender Woman Alexa Negrón Luciano
    October 2, 2023
    Trans and Non-Binary Activists Challenge Florida’s Bathroom Ban as Unconstitutional
    October 2, 2023
    Uganda’s Anti-Gay Law Spurs Surge in LGBTQ Abuse
    September 29, 2023
  • Health
    Health
    Show More
    Top News
    Florida’s Restrictive Laws Leave Transgender Adults Struggling for Care
    June 5, 2023
    Nebraska Governor Signs Bill Banning Abortion and Gender-Affirming Care for Trans Youth, Amidst Controversy and Lack of Understanding
    May 24, 2023
    South Dakota Governor Signs Bill Banning Gender-Affirming Care for Transgender Youth
    February 14, 2023
    Latest News
    Renewed Focus on HIV Vaccine Trial: A Step Towards Prevention
    October 2, 2023
    PEPFAR Faces Uncertain Future Amidst Conservative Opposition
    September 30, 2023
    Federal Appeals Court Allows Tennessee and Kentucky to Enforce Bans on Gender-Affirming Care for Minors
    September 29, 2023
    Catalonia Takes Bold Step to Combat Period Poverty
    September 22, 2023
  • Money
    Money
    Show More
    Top News
    Target Adjusts Pride Displays Amid Customer Complaints
    May 24, 2023
    Anheuser-Busch faces backlash over partnership with transgender influencer and Pride-themed Bud Light cans
    April 10, 2023
    Bud Light Defends Trans Influencer Partnership in March Madness Campaign Amid Backlash
    April 16, 2023
    Latest News
    Iceland Supermarket CEO Retracts HIV Needle Attack Claims, Faces Criticism
    September 23, 2023
    Disney CEO Addresses Culture War Amid Investment Surge
    September 22, 2023
    Challenges and Consequences: Bud Light’s Controversial Dive into LGBTQ+ Marketing
    September 20, 2023
    Chick-Fil-A Plans UK Expansion Amidst Past LGBT Controversy
    September 17, 2023
  • Sports
    Sports
    Show More
    Top News
    Australia players call out Qatar on LGBTQ, worker rights
    October 27, 2022
    Qatar World Cup ambassador says homosexuality is ‘damage in the mind’
    November 8, 2022
    Shocking Homophobic Slurs: Top Basketball Coach’s Controversial Radio Interview Exposed
    May 10, 2023
    Latest News
    Controversy Surrounds Trans Inclusion in English Women’s Fishing Team
    October 2, 2023
    AEW World Trios Champion Anthony Bowens on Embracing His Authentic Self
    October 2, 2023
    Carrie Prejean Boller and Megyn Kelly Criticize Megan Rapinoe as Soccer Star Retires
    September 30, 2023
    Megan Rapinoe Bids Farewell to International Football in Spectacular Fashion
    September 26, 2023
  • Media
    Media
    Show More
    Top News
    ‘Eternals,’ ‘Mitchells,’ ‘Supergirl,’ ‘Star Trek’ lead GLAAD Awards
    January 23, 2022
    Trans Rights in Peril: RuPaul’s Drag Race Star Issues Urgent Warning
    February 5, 2023
    Iraq Restricts Media Language Pertaining to Sexual Identity
    August 9, 2023
    Latest News
    North Carolina Radio Station Refuses to Play Met Opera’s LGBTQ+ Themed Operas
    October 2, 2023
    GB News Suspends Third Presenter Amid Controversial Comments Fallout
    October 1, 2023
    Florida Governor Ron DeSantis Defends Anti-LGBTQ+ Stance, Blames Media
    September 18, 2023
    Madonna’s Uncompromising Artistic Integrity Shines as Pepsi Revisits Controversial Ad
    September 14, 2023
  • Activism
    Activism
    Show More
    Top News
    Sydney’s WorldPride 2023 Begins with a Bang: Check out the Photos from Mardi Gras Fair Day
    February 19, 2023
    Sydney Opera House Illuminated in Pride Progress Flag for WorldPride 2023
    February 19, 2023
    Thousands join Budapest Pride march against anti-LGBTQ law
    July 27, 2021
    Latest News
    Massive Turnout at London Pride Protest Against Anti-LGBTQ+ Comments by Suella Braverman
    October 2, 2023
    Trans and Non-Binary Activists Challenge Florida’s Bathroom Ban as Unconstitutional
    October 2, 2023
    Haifa’s Neve Sha’anan to Host LGBTQ Family Event Amidst Controversy
    October 2, 2023
    Trans Influencer Dylan Mulvaney Honored as 2023 Suicide Prevention Advocate of the Year
    October 1, 2023
  • Lifestyle
    Lifestyle
    Show More
    Top News
    Club Q in Colorado Springs Announces Plans to Rebuild and Reopen After Shooting Tragedy
    February 14, 2023
    More Britons identify as bisexual than gay or lesbian – survey
    October 9, 2022
    Italy’s Crackdown on LGBT Parents Sparks Outrage Among Rainbow Families
    April 6, 2023
    Latest News
    Anderson Cooper’s Hilarious Tale of His Mother’s Surrogate Offer
    October 1, 2023
    Transgender Father Stands Firm in Defense of Daughter’s Rights in Utah
    September 30, 2023
    Controversy Surrounds Same-Sex Sikh Wedding in Conservative India
    September 26, 2023
    Anderson Cooper Reflects on Parenthood and Confronting Grief
    September 23, 2023
Reading: Calif. court strikes law on transgender pronoun use in nursing homes
Share
Aa
The Pink Times
Search
  • Home
  • World News
    • Africa
    • Americas
    • Asia Pacific
    • China
    • Europe
    • India
    • Middle East
    • United Kingdom
    • United States
  • Culture
    • Art
    • Drag
    • Books
    • Entertainment
    • Drag
    • Fashion
    • History
    • Love
    • People
    • PhotographyTrending
    • Religion
  • Politics
  • Law
  • Health
  • Money
  • Sports
  • Media
  • Activism
  • Lifestyle
Have an existing account? Sign In
Follow US
The Pink Times > World News > United States > Calif. court strikes law on transgender pronoun use in nursing homes
LawUnited States

Calif. court strikes law on transgender pronoun use in nursing homes

The Pink Times
The Pink Times August 7, 2021
Updated 2021/08/07 at 10:35 PM
Share

July 30 (UPI) — California’s 3rd District Court of Appeal has struck down a provision in a state law that made it a crime for staff members at nursing homes to “willfully and repeatedly fail to use a resident’s preferred name or pronouns after being clearly informed of the preferred name or pronouns.”

In a 3-0 ruling, the court says the provision — which was enacted in 2017 by the state Legislature as part of the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual and Transgender Long-Term Care Facility Residents’ Bill of Rights — violates the employees’ freedom of speech.

- Advertisement -
Ad imageAd image

Intentionally using the wrong name or pronouns was a misdemeanor with a maximum punishment of 180 days in jail and a $2,500 fine.

“We recognize that misgendering may be disrespectful, discourteous and insulting and used as an inartful way to express an ideological disagreement with another person’s expressed gender identity,” Justice Elena Duarte wrote for the court. “But the First Amendment does not protect only speech that inoffensively and artfully articulates a person’s point of view. At the very least, willful refusal to refer to transgender persons by their preferred pronouns conveys general disagreement with the concept that a person’s gender identity may be different from the sex the person was assigned at birth.”

Duarte also wrote that the provision restricts more speech than is necessary to achieve the government’s compelling interest in eliminating discrimination and harassment on the basis of sex.

In a concurrence, Justice Ronald Robie wrote “to not call one by the name one prefers or the pronoun one prefers, is simply rude, insulting and cruel.”

However, he also said that instead of mandating employers ensure the use of proper pronouns in the workplace, the California Legislature “unwisely” made their misuse a crime.

“When we rule this law cannot stand, we do not reject the need for persons to use appropriate pronouns but, in my opinion, are suggesting that the Legislature fashion a workable means of accomplishing the laudable goal of the legislation,” Robie wrote.

The decision upholds a separate provision mandating that when assigning rooms based on gender, long-term care facilities and their staffs must make decisions based only on a transgender resident’s gender identity.

The California Attorney General’s Office, which defended the law, is reviewing the decision, according to an email from its press office.

‘Hateful act’

Rick Chavez Zbur, executive director of Equality California, which sponsored the legislation, said the decision is disappointing, especially for the transgender and nonbinary seniors.

Refusing to use someone’s correct name and pronouns isn’t an issue of free speech but a “hateful act that denies someone their dignity and truth,” he said

“Study after study has shown that trans people who are misgendered face alarming and life-threatening rates of depression and suicidal behavior,” Zbur said in an email. “And older LGBTQ+ people face feelings of isolation, poor mental health and extreme vulnerability to communicable diseases like COVID-19. California’s nursing home patients deserve better than this — and we’ll be fighting until this decision is overturned.”

An entity called Taking Offense — which the ruling describes as an “unincorporated association which includes at least one California citizen and taxpayer” — filed suit in 2017 seeking a declaration that the two provisions are unconstitutional.

The association argued the room assignment provision is a violation of the First Amendment right to freedom of association. It also said the pronoun provision is vague and overbroad and violates staff members’ rights to free speech, free exercise of religion and freedoms of thought and belief.

The pronoun provision “requires a traditional religious Christian, Muslim, Jew or believer in any other religious faith that affirms ‘conforming’ doctrines regarding sexual roles, gender identity and gender expression as the will of God, binding on believers’ consciences, to deny their faith and to blaspheme against their religion and conscience in order to work at a licensed long-term care facility in California, with no provision in the law for a ‘reasonable accommodation’ to protect the rights of such religious employees,” Taking Offense claimed.

After a Superior Court judge in Sacramento denied the association’s request to overturn the provisions, Taking Offense appealed.

David Llewellyn, a Fair Oaks, Calif., attorney for Taking Offense, said Monday his office is not doing interviews about the case.

“My only comment is that free speech should not be subject to criminal penalties, regardless of its content,” Llewellyn said in an email.

State Sen. Scott Wiener, D-San Francisco, who authored the legislation, told UPI that he strongly disagrees with the ruling.

“The law does not penalize someone for a slip of the tongue,” he said, adding the pronoun provision stops staff members from deliberately misgendering transgender residents, an action that he describes as “straight-up harassment.”

“These are some of the most vulnerable members of our society,” Wiener said. “I am committed to continue the fight for these seniors.”

Religious objections

Pronoun use has been at the center of other lawsuits.

Tanner Cross, a physical education teacher in Virginia, sued after Loudoun County Public Schools suspended him in May for conduct that allegedly had “a disruptive impact on the operations of Leesburg Elementary School.”

During a public comment period at a school board meeting, Cross spoke against a proposed policy that would require transgender students to be addressed by their preferred pronouns. The teacher said it was against his religion to use pronouns that do not correspond with a student’s biological sex.

A judge ruled in June that Cross had been speaking on a matter of public concern as a citizen, rather than in his official capacity, and ordered him reinstated pending resolution of the lawsuit.

In 2018, Nicholas Meriwether, a philosophy professor at Shawnee State University in Portsmouth, Ohio, was disciplined for declining to address a transgender student with female pronouns as required under the school’s gender identity policy.

Meriwether, a devout Christian, said he offered to call on the student using her last name alone, but the compromise was unacceptable to university officials and a warning letter was put in his file, according to court documents.

The warning letter will make it difficult, if not impossible, for him to obtain a position at another institution once he retires from Shawnee State, Meriwether said. He filed a lawsuit accusing the university of violating his free speech and free exercise of religion rights. The case is pending.

TAGGED: California, transgender, Virginia

Join Us!

Subscribe to our newsletter and never miss our latest news, podcasts and more!
Please wait...

Thank you for sign up!

Zero spam, Unsubscribe at any time.
The Pink Times August 7, 2021
Share this Article
Facebook Twitter Whatsapp Whatsapp LinkedIn Tumblr Reddit VKontakte Telegram Email
Share

Latest Articles

Colorado County Commissioner Faces Backlash for Alleged Anti-LGBTQ Slur
Politics United States
Meta Under Fire: Anti-LGBTQ+ Hate Speech Thrives on Facebook, Instagram, and Threads
Tech
India: Telangana High Court Strikes Down 1919 Act, Ensuring Rights for Transgender Community
India Law
Jacob Elordi and Emerald Fennell Tease Darkly Comedic Thriller Saltburn
Film
California Governor Appoints Laphonza Butler, First Openly LGBTQ+ Senator to Represent the State
Politics United States

Most Viewed Posts

  • Hot Photos from Paul’s Book “Larrikin Prince” Unleashed
  • A Shift in Perspective: The Art of Male Nude Photography
  • Vintage Nude Mormon Bodybuilders: Unveiling the Forbidden Past of Utah’s Physique Models
  • Hot and Sexy: A Visual Exploration of Masculine Bravado and Regal Splendor
  • The Ginger Sensation of RuPaul’s Drag Race: A Tribute to Bryce Eilenberg
The Pink Times
Follow US

All rights reserved

News. Culture. Tea.

Must-read stories we're talking about across our community. Sign up for The Pink Times newsletter

Please wait...

Thank you for sign up!

Zero spam, Unsubscribe at any time.

Removed from reading list

Undo
Welcome Back!

Sign in to your account

Register Lost your password?