In the ever-evolving world of LGBTQ fashion, an unexpected debate has emerged, shedding light on the controversial topic of “top shaming.” The catalyst for this discourse? A seemingly innocuous query posed on the social media platform X. The question, directed at the self-proclaimed ‘tops’ of the LGBTQ community, challenged their choice of attire, particularly the jockstrap.
The Origins of the Debate
The discussion ignited on a fateful morning in October 2023 when the creator of the card game “Poof the Game” took to X to question, “Why are you, a top, wearing a jockstrap?” At first glance, it appeared to be a reasonable inquiry, questioning whether the jockstrap’s design, with its easy access to intimate areas, justified a touch of “top shaming.”
However, the history of the jockstrap tells a different story. Originally crafted as a sporting garment to provide unparalleled freedom of movement, the jockstrap’s roots extend back to early 20th-century boxing matches, where champion boxer Billy Papke famously sported it as his sole attire during bouts.

The Jockstrap’s Evolution within the LGBTQ Community
The narrative took a turn when the LGBTQ community discovered the aesthetic appeal of the jockstrap, showcasing the contours of a well-defined posterior while maintaining unimpeded access to desired pleasures. This discovery led to its popularity among physique photographers and eventually within the realm of adult entertainment. Soon, jockstraps emerged in a kaleidoscope of colors and fabrics, from leather to rhinestones, even edible renditions, offering something for everyone.
A Multifaceted Response
In response to the jockstrap query, numerous jockstrap-wearing tops flooded the platform with their diverse opinions and sometimes explicit perspectives. While some responses remain NSFW, they underscore the complexity of this discussion within the LGBTQ community.
As the debate surrounding “top shaming” continues to unfold, it raises questions about the intersections of fashion, identity, and self-expression within the diverse tapestry of LGBTQ culture. Whether it’s a playful debate or a serious examination of societal norms, it reminds us that the LGBTQ community is a vibrant, ever-evolving landscape where fashion choices can carry profound significance.