Joanna Cherry, an SNP MP and a self-identified lesbian, has raised concerns in the UK Commons about the impact of trans rights activism on women’s rights. Her comments came a day after the international Trans Day of Remembrance, which commemorates trans individuals lost to violence.
The Request for a Rapid Review
Cherry has urged the government to conduct a “rapid review” into the activism of trans rights groups and their influence on women’s rights, including those of lesbians. She referenced a letter to Prime Minister Rishi Sunak, endorsed by 15,000 people including gender-critical activists Maya Forstater and Helen Joyce, highlighting alleged instances of violence, intimidation, and threats against women advocating for sex-based rights.
Government’s Response
Laura Farris, the under-secretary of state at the Home Office and ministry of justice, acknowledged Cherry’s concerns. Farris, whose work focuses on safeguarding and tackling violence against women and girls, condemned the described actions and recognized the legal protection of gender-critical beliefs. She expressed her willingness to discuss the matter further with Cherry, including potential next steps.
Cherry’s Gender-Critical Stance and Controversies
Cherry has been a controversial figure due to her gender-critical views, often conflicting with many of her SNP colleagues. She has faced pushback for her stance, including a canceled event at the Edinburgh Festival Fringe, which was later reinstated following her threat of legal action. Cherry has also been a critic of Scotland’s gender law reforms and suggested that conversion therapy should remain legal in some contexts.
The Polarizing Debate
This development underscores the ongoing and polarizing debate in the UK over gender identity and women’s rights. Cherry’s call for a review highlights the complexities and tensions at the intersection of these issues, reflecting the need for careful consideration and dialogue in addressing the concerns of all affected groups. The government’s response to this call will be closely watched as it navigates the sensitive and often contentious terrain of gender rights and freedoms.