In a recent private meeting with Portuguese members of the Jesuit order, Pope Francis openly criticized what he deemed as “backwardness” within certain conservative factions of the U.S. Catholic Church. Expressing concern that some individuals have moved from faith to ideology, the pontiff underscored that a genuine interpretation of Catholic doctrine allows for its evolution over time.
During the meeting held in Lisbon on August 5, Pope Francis acknowledged a Portuguese Jesuit’s account of facing criticism from U.S. Catholics, including bishops, during a sabbatical year in the United States. He highlighted the prevailing “strong, organized, reactionary attitude” within the U.S. church, which he believes disconnects it from the true tradition and roots of the faith, resulting in adverse effects on morality.
“The vision of the doctrine of the church as a monolith is wrong,” Pope Francis asserted, noting that moving backward leads to a closed-off understanding of the faith. He stressed the need for a correct evolution in comprehending matters of faith and morals, urging a departure from rigid ideologies that replace true faith.
The Pope’s comments resonated with many, garnering applause and shared sentiments. These remarks acknowledge the profound divisions present within the U.S. Catholic Church, stemming historically from contrasting stances held by progressives and conservatives, especially on issues like abortion and same-sex marriage. As Pope Francis prioritizes social justice concerns and shifts the Church’s focus, resistance from conservative quarters persists, particularly regarding his inclusive stance on matters like divorced and remarried Catholics participating in sacraments.
Pope Francis’ candid remarks serve as a recognition of the complex dynamics within the U.S. Catholic Church, highlighting the ongoing dialogue between faith and ideology and the significance of evolving interpretations of doctrine to stay aligned with the core values of the faith.