Megan Park’s latest directorial venture, “My Old Ass,” starring the versatile Maisy Stella and the ever-charismatic Aubrey Plaza, made a notable debut at Sundance 2024. The film presents a coming-of-age story set against the backdrop of a Canadian cranberry farm, where 18-year-old Elliott Labrant, played by Stella, embarks on a life-altering psychedelic journey. This unexpected trip down memory lane, or rather, into the future, introduces her to her 39-year-old self, portrayed by Plaza, bringing a blend of humor and wisdom to the screen.
The narrative explores the complexities of family bonds and the essence of time, as older Elliott advises her younger self to cherish family moments and steer clear of certain life choices, particularly involving a boy named Chad. The film intricately weaves the layers of Elliott’s identity, primarily her sexuality. Identifying as a lesbian, Elliott’s life takes an unexpected turn when she encounters Chad, a boy with deep ties to her family’s cranberry farm. Their ensuing relationship challenges her preconceived notions of love and attraction, sparking a conversation about the fluidity of sexuality.
However, the film’s portrayal of bisexuality strikes a discordant note. Elliott’s journey from a self-identified lesbian to someone exploring a deep connection with a man seems rushed and lacking depth. This transition, while aiming to highlight the fluid nature of sexual identity, unfortunately skirts around the nuances of bisexual experiences. The film attempts to address the policing of labels within the queer community, but its execution falls short of delivering a truly authentic bisexual narrative.
Despite these shortcomings, “My Old Ass” captivates with its heartfelt performances and a script that balances comedy with poignant moments of self-realization. Aubrey Plaza’s performance stands out, bridging the gap between the two Elliotts with remarkable ease. The film, though flawed in its exploration of queer identity, remains a significant entry in the realm of LGBTQ cinema, offering a perspective on the evolving understanding of sexuality and identity.